Dark Souls II is considered the weakest Souls game by some players because it feels different from the original in its world design, combat and progression—and because some encounters, particularly in Scholar of the First Sin, strike critics as crowded or unfair. That is a reaction, not a settled consensus: the sequel has defenders, and Hidetaka Miyazaki later praised it as a project that helped the series develop.
What do critics object to?
The recurring complaint is less that Dark Souls II is difficult than that its difficulty and design feel different from what some players valued in the first Dark Souls. Retrospective criticism commonly points to the world and level design, combat changes, boss encounters, perceived cheapness, and the health loss and recovery systems. These are criticisms players make, not objective verdicts that every player shares. Den of Geek’s 2024 retrospective describes the dispute and the objections behind the game’s reputation.
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
Dark Souls Trilogy (PS4) | $38.80 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
|
Dark Souls II: Scholar of the First Sin - PlayStation 4 | $21.39 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
|
Dark Souls III: The Fire Fades Edition - Xbox One | $24.80 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
|
Dark Souls: Remastered (Nintendo Switch) | $43.79 | Buy on Amazon |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
For returning players, the issue can be a mismatch of expectations: a sequel carrying the same name and broad challenge-oriented identity does not necessarily reproduce the particular structure or feel they wanted. The available accounts establish that these differences are frequently criticized, but do not provide a feature-by-feature technical comparison that would settle whether one game’s design is better.
Outdated Drivers Are Slowing You Down
One free scan finds every outdated or missing driver and matches the right update for your exact hardware.Free scan · exact hardware matchWindows Errors? Fix Them Before They Spread
Repair common Windows errors and clear accumulated junk for a smoother, more stable PC - no reinstall needed.Free scan · no reinstallWhy can the difficulty feel unfair?
Players who see an encounter as a learnable test may find it satisfying; players who read it as crowded, poorly signposted or punishing may experience frustration instead. That distinction helps explain why the argument is about tuning and fairness as much as raw difficulty.
#1 Best Overall
- DARK SOULS REMASTERED - Then, there was fire. Re-experience the genre-defining game that started it all. Return to Lordran in the beautifully remastered game in high definition, 60 fps with single-player or online multiplayer with dedicated servers. Includes the Artorias of the Abyss DLC.
- DARK SOULS II: SCHOLAR OF THE FIRST SIN - Prepare to Die again. The second installment of the series includes the base Dark Souls II plus all three DLCs: Crown of the Sunken King, Crown of the Old Iron King, and Crown of the Ivory King.
- DARK SOULS III: THE FIRE FADES - Now only embers remain… Dark Souls III is the final journey in the series where players can fight through intense combat solo or team up for in co-op or PvP multiplayer. Includes the award-winning game and both DLC chapters: Ashes of Ariandel and The Ringed City.
- ALL ORIGINAL SOUNDTRACKS - Visit the EP!C corner to download the music of the Dark Souls saga composed by Motoi Sakaraba and Yuka Kitamura. 110 tracks and more than 6 hours to listen and take back any Dark Souls fan to the intense boss fights and the best moments of their deadly journeys.
Director Yui Tanimura said the team’s use of “accessible” did not mean making the game easier. He described the aim as streamlining tedious parts while retaining difficulty, and said balance and enemy placement were central responsibilities. Those comments explain the intended approach, but cannot establish that every player found the result fair. Tanimura’s 2013 interview with Game Informer discusses that design goal.
Miyazaki later described FromSoftware’s broader target as deaths players can understand and learn from: “When players are killed, and they can understand why they were killed in an instance, and it feels justified – ‘Okay, yeah, that makes sense’ – that’s the game design we’re trying to achieve.” That is a statement of intent, not evidence that Dark Souls II always meets it. Game Informer’s 2024 interview with Miyazaki gives the context for his view of difficulty.
Rank #2
- All 3 DLC Pack Contents: Crown of the Sunken King, Crown of the Old Iron King, Crown of the Ivory King
- Additional NPCs Added For Enhanced Story Experience To Assist Guiding Players Through Level
- Parameter Setting Adjustments for Improved Balance
- Augmented Item Descriptions
- Increase in Maximum Online Players
Does Scholar of the First Sin change the experience?
Yes. Scholar of the First Sin is not simply a presentation update: producer Atsuo Yoshimura said it revised enemy placement across areas, improved enemy AI and added enemies in places players had treated as safer. He also said enemies could pursue players farther and that the number appearing together could make Scholar somewhat harder. So a complaint about enemy density should be tied to the edition being discussed, rather than assumed to describe every release in the same way. Yoshimura’s 2015 interview with GameSpot explains the changes.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errors2Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches3Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problemsYoshimura characterized Scholar as a director’s-cut-style revision incorporating development ideas and fan suggestions, while describing the overall balance as broadly similar. That is the producer’s account; players may still judge the changes differently. For more on the revision and its reception, see Game Developer’s 2015 interview with Yoshimura.
Rank #3
- The Complete Dark Souls III Experience All on One Disc: Includes the award-winning base game, PLUS both complete DLC expansion chapters: Ashes of Ariandel and The Ringed City.
- Intense Combat Action: Challenging, genre-defining gameplay. Diversified combat action allows players to craft their own unique style.
- Team up for some jolly good cooperation or test your ability in PvP battle: All PvP maps unlocked and accessible. Improved online matchmaking functionality.
Can a progression mechanic be both helpful and frustrating?
A contemporary TIME review described enemies disappearing after repeated defeats. The reviewer saw a tradeoff: fewer enemies can make a repeatedly traveled route less dangerous, but the mechanic can also encourage cautious soul-hoarding and anxiety about moving ahead underprepared. That is one reviewer’s interpretation, not a universal response to the system. TIME’s 2014 piece on enemy despawning lays out both sides.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Did the director change cause the backlash?
It became part of the debate, but it does not by itself explain the game’s reputation. Yui Tanimura directed Dark Souls II; retrospective coverage also names Tomohiro Shibuya as a director. Miyazaki did not direct it, but Yoshimura said he supervised and commented on changes. Yoshimura acknowledged that some fans questioned whether the game was the “real Dark Souls” without Miyazaki directing, then rejected that conclusion: “The answer is — to me, it’s no. It’s sharing the same DNA. It’s from the same franchise.” His interview with Game Developer captures both the concern and his response.
Rank #4
- Delve into an epic dark fantasy universe stricken by decline and the Curse
- Each playthrough surprises you with new challenges and unexpected facets of the game
- Hundreds of unique combinations of weaponry, armour, magic and crafting options to create your own play style and gaming experience
- From your first steps to mastery, build your character while refining your playing skills. Learn to strategise freely and experience the rewarding taste of overcoming daunting foes
- Compatible with Nintendo Switch only
Is its reputation fair?
It is fair to say Dark Souls II is divisive and that some players find its design a poor fit with what they wanted from a direct sequel. It is not fair to turn that preference into a claim that everyone considers the game bad or that its most criticized encounters describe every edition equally.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
Miyazaki later called Dark Souls II “a really great project for us,” saying it generated connections and ideas that carried forward through the series. A 2024 retrospective also connects its experimentation to later series ideas such as world scale, boss distribution, build options and powerstancing; those connections are the retrospective’s interpretation of influence, not a claim that Miyazaki specifically credited each feature. The game can disappoint players seeking a closer continuation of the first Dark Souls and still matter as an experiment in the series’ evolution. Den of Geek’s 2024 retrospective discusses Miyazaki’s reassessment and the sequel’s legacy.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
