Earth’s water most likely came from more than one source. Water-bearing rocky material—especially material resembling carbonaceous chondrites—has strong isotopic support as a major contributor. Comets could have added some water, and one 2018 model proposes a small contribution from hydrogen captured from the solar nebula. Volcanic outgassing later carried water from Earth’s interior to the surface. Scientists have not established exact source percentages or a single delivery timeline.
Why Earth’s water needs more than one explanation
Earth formed in the hot inner Solar System, where surface water was difficult to retain. Explaining today’s oceans therefore involves more than asking whether water existed in the early Solar System: it requires a plausible way to deliver hydrogen and water-bearing material to Earth, account for losses during heating and impacts, and explain how water held inside the planet reached the surface.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Earth’s growth involved repeated accretion and volatile loss. A 2022 review in Nature Reviews Earth & Environment places the Moon-forming impact at approximately 70–120 million years after Solar System formation and says more than 98% of Earth’s mass had accreted by then. That is a broad formation chronology, not a date for the oceans or proof that their water arrived in one event.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
What isotope evidence can—and cannot—tell us
Hydrogen occurs mainly as ordinary hydrogen and the heavier isotope deuterium. The deuterium-to-hydrogen ratio, or D/H, can help compare water in Earth, meteorites and comets. Deuterium is more likely to be concentrated in water formed in cold environments, so a similar ratio can support a connection between two reservoirs.
#1 Best Overall
- BUILD & DISPLAY A MOVING, GLOWING SOLAR SYSTEM – With this kit, kids can customize all 8 planets and the sun, creating a stunning 3D solar system model that glows in the dark! It’s an awesome addition to any space-themed room.
- ALL-INCLUSIVE KIT – Everything needed to build a glowing solar system is included: 6 vibrant paint colors, glow-in-the-dark accent paint, brush, palette, fun decals, and a poster with solar system facts! Kid-friendly instructions make assembly easy!
- MOVABLE ARMS FOR EASY ADJUSTMENTS – Adjust the position of the planets with ease! The model’s movable arms allow kids to set up and rearrange their solar system display to match their imagination.
- LEARN HANDS-ON FUN FACTS ABOUT OUR SOLAR SYSTEM – Dive into the wonders of space with this engaging model kit! Kids will learn fascinating facts about each planet as they build and explore their own glow-in-the-dark solar system.
- AWARD-WINNING PRODUCTS - Blue Marble, winner of the Toy Association's prestigious Toy of the Year Award, proudly develops products that foster education, imagination, and creativity, with a U.S. support team to ensure a stellar experience!
NASA Science reports that Earth’s oceans contain about one deuterium atom for every 6,420 hydrogen atoms. But D/H is not a unique source label: comet measurements vary, and chemical processing in the early Solar System’s disk complicates attempts to infer where water formed. As the 2019 review of the debate explains, isotope evidence must be considered alongside other isotope systems and possible transport routes. A match supports a relationship; by itself, it does not identify a unique parent body, prove a delivery event, or establish how much water that source supplied.
How the proposed sources compare
| Proposed source or process | What supports it | What remains uncertain |
|---|---|---|
| Water-bearing rocky bodies, including carbonaceous-chondrite-like material | Water in carbonaceous chondrites has a D/H ratio described as a reasonable match for terrestrial water in the reviewed model literature. Dynamical scenarios also provide routes for outer Solar System material to reach the terrestrial planets. | Similarity does not establish that the meteorites sampled are the exact source population, identify a particular asteroid or delivery event, or determine the fraction of Earth’s water they supplied. |
| Comets | Some Jupiter-family comets have measured D/H values similar to Earth’s, making a cometary contribution plausible. | Comets do not all have the same measured ratio. In the comparison reported by NASA Science, water from comet 67P had about three times the oceanic deuterium abundance. |
| Hydrogen from the solar nebula | A 2018 model describes nebular hydrogen dissolving into magma oceans, reacting with iron and partly entering the core, with isotope fractionation between the core and mantle. | NASA Astrobiology’s 2018 summary of the model estimates that about one in 100 of Earth’s water molecules traces to the nebula. This is a model-dependent estimate, not a direct measurement or evidence that nebular gas supplied most surface-ocean water. |
| Earth’s interior and volcanic outgassing | Volcanic vapor could vent from the young planet and condense as rain. The 2018 model also discusses the possibility that several oceans’ worth of hydrogen reside in the mantle and core. | Outgassing describes how water moves from Earth’s interior to its surface; it does not, by itself, explain the original source of the hydrogen. |
Why asteroids are a leading explanation
Carbonaceous chondrites are meteorites that contain water-bearing minerals. Their hydrogen-isotope values are reasonably close to those of terrestrial water, which supports the idea that similar rocky bodies contributed substantially to Earth’s water. Reviewed accretion scenarios also offer ways for material from beyond Earth’s immediate neighborhood to be incorporated into the growing planet.
Rank #2
- 【SET CONTENT】The solar system kit includes 7.87 inches of foam discs, 1 sun, 12 foam balls of different shapes, 4 foam stars, 15 bamboo sticks 15 toothpick flags, 12 Colors, 2 Brushes, 1 palette, 1 instruction. The Solar System Model Kit provides everything kids need to carry out solar system projects, kids can easily start solar system projects in school or at home!
- 【Space Enlightenment】The Solar System Model Kit allows kids to color and build their own solar system model, providing kids a more intuitive understanding of the planet in the solar system. With a Solar System Instruction, which introduces kids to the relevant details of the solar system, sparking their curiosity and desire to explore astronomy and science!
- 【High Quality】The solar system science kit for kids 3-5 is made of durable polystyrene foam with a smooth surface that's easy to color, and includes 12 acrylic paints, which are safe and odorless. Kids can use their imagination to create the planets of the school solar system project!
- 【Learning by Playing】The solar system project kit helps kids build skills through fun. Creating planets not only improves kids hand-eye coordination and focus, but also boosts their scientific knowledge and artistic skills.
- 【Wide Application】The Solar System Kit is perfect for themes and activities about the solar system and planets. It’s great for enhancing classroom learning about the solar system and also makes a fun family activity.
That evidence does not settle whether the water arrived mainly in a late addition of carbonaceous material or whether Earth inherited much of its hydrogen earlier, in different building blocks. Heating, impacts and accretion could remove or redistribute volatiles, and the meteorites available for study may not represent every population that contributed to Earth.
Did comets deliver Earth’s water?
They may have delivered some, but current evidence does not establish comets as the dominant source—or rule them out. Some measured comet ratios are close to Earth’s, while 67P’s water had about three times the oceanic deuterium abundance in NASA Science’s reported comparison. Neither one matching comet nor one differing comet can stand in for all comets.
Rank #3
- Solar system model kit: package comes with 12 pieces foam balls, 2 pieces foam rings, 15 pieces bamboo sticks, 15 pieces toothpick flags, 12 color pigments, 2 pieces painting brushes, 1 pieces paint tray palette. Now securely shipped in a sturdy cardboard box to guarantee all pieces arrive undamaged and ready for your project.
- Variety of Sizes for Visual Learning: The kit includes 10 differently sized foam balls (as pictured) to visually represent the relative scale and hierarchy of the Sun, planets, and Pluto. This hands-on approach helps learners easily observe and understand planetary size relationships.
- Upgraded Premium Paint Set: Features our enhanced paint set with 12 vibrant colors (increased from 8), each in a larger 5ml pot for richer coverage, longer use, and more creative possibilities.
- Easy to assemble: You can identify the different planets by writing the planet's name on a blank toothpick flag and inserting it into a foam ball. No glue required, they can be easily assembled using bamboo skewers, create your planetary model to understand how our solar system is arranged.
- Fun learning tool: You and your kids had a great time painting and putting this together and learnt a lot about the planets in the process. It was a decent lesson representing the Solar system for a young child. Perfect for handmade craft, DIY decoration, school project, science projects and more.
NASA Science reports that researchers reanalyzed more than 16,000 Rosetta measurements of 67P because dust could affect observed isotope ratios. That work illustrates why comet measurements need careful interpretation; it does not turn the measurements of one comet into a final answer for Earth. The NASA account quoted planetary scientist Kathleen Mandt saying, “It was really starting to look like these comets played a major role in delivering water to Earth.” The statement reflects the context of that comet research, not a settled consensus that comets supplied most of Earth’s water.
How water moved from Earth’s interior to the oceans
Delivery and outgassing are different parts of the story. Water-bearing material could have added hydrogen to the growing Earth, while volcanic activity released water vapor from its interior. As the surface cooled, vapor could condense and fall as rain, contributing to surface water.
Rank #4
- CURIOUS KIDS FAVORITE TOY: Playz Electric Solar System Model Kit teaches your little astronomer the wonders of our galaxy with a 4 speed orbit motor. Ours is the biggest space toys model kit available in the USA. Perfect astronomy gift for kids!
- HANDS ON PROJECT: 75+ premium parts combined with a color instruction manual makes for an intuitive DIY assembly. Loaded with fun educational facts about physics, astronomy, science, and engineering. Large model measures 26" x 18" x 11"
- OUTER SPACE CREATIVITY: Children can paint their own planets with the included paint set and foam balls or use the high quality laser painted planets for an excellent science fair or school project display!
- STUNNING VIEWS: The sun is a portable HD projector that projects 8 beautiful planets on any surface! Many kids use it as a cool nightlight or flashlight. (4x AA BATTERIES NOT INCLUDED)
- "TRUST OUR PLAYZ PROMISE - Do your research! You know the quality you will get when purchasing a Playz solar system kit. If you are unhappy with your purchase, contact us at anytime for a refund.
Some hydrogen may also have remained in the mantle or core. The 2018 model discusses several oceans’ worth of hydrogen potentially stored in those deep reservoirs. That possibility means Earth’s total water inventory is not the same thing as the water in its oceans; it also leaves open how much water cycled between the interior and surface over geological time.
What scientists have not settled
- The exact share of Earth’s water supplied by asteroids, comets, nebular hydrogen or other early building blocks.
- Whether sampled carbonaceous chondrites represent the material that actually contributed to Earth.
- How much water arrived in later additions versus being inherited earlier during Earth’s growth.
- The precise sequence and timing of delivery, volatile loss, interior storage and ocean formation.
Accretion reviews emphasize that volatile additions and losses occurred as Earth grew, and that early nebular volatiles largely escaped or were diluted. Because the sources, transport routes and losses are interconnected, the best-supported account remains a mixed-origin one rather than a single-source claim.
Quick Recap
Best Value
- Science Kits for Kids 8-12: Complete model solar system for kids includes wood set, puzzle, and fun fact cards. This two part DIY solar system kit allows kids to build a cool model, paint, and learn about the major 9 planets. Designed for 8 & up.
- Science Fairs & More: Bring the planets to life with our Nine Planets kit. Makes the perfect realistic solar system model for elementary school science fairs & more. Proudly display in a bedroom, science fair, or classroom. For girls and & boys.
- Planetary Enlightenment: Foster a love for learning with our solar system project, an engaging educational science kit that makes complex concepts easy to understand and enjoyable for young minds. Includes fact cards for quick and accurate solar system information.
- Planetary Delight: Unleash creativity and curiosity with our solar system project kit . Children will delight in their exploration of the universe while having fun accomplishing this all in one kit. We offer the perfect science kits for kids age 8-12.
- Craft & Learn: Everything you need to build the wood model, paint the major planets, and build the puzzle. Includes The Sun, Mercury, Earth, Jupiter, Uranus, Venus, Mars, Saturn, and Neptune. Includes paint and brushes. Build the model in approximately 1-2 hours.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
