Some water confined inside self-assembling, specially designed lipid structures can avoid crystallizing below zero. In a 2019 study, researchers reported amorphous water in these nanostructures down to about 10 kelvin (−263 °C). That is not ordinary bulk water remaining liquid at that temperature: the water’s state depends on its confinement, the lipid structure and the amount of water present.
What the researchers made
The team studied synthetic monoacylglycerols with cyclopropyl modifications in their hydrophobic chains. By changing the number and position of those groups, along with chain length and curvature, the researchers created lipids that assemble with water into ordered structures. These include lamellar phases and bicontinuous cubic phases, in which water occupies nanoscale domains.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The primary study, by Livia Salvati Manni and colleagues, combined experimental measurements with molecular-dynamics simulations to examine how water behaves in those structures. The authors describe a complex lipid–water phase diagram: depending on composition and phase, confined water can be subzero liquid, glassy, amorphous or crystalline ice. Read the study in Nature Nanotechnology.
Recommended Free Tools
Why confinement can inhibit ice formation
To form ice, water molecules must arrange into an ordered crystal. In a sufficiently small, structured environment, that arrangement can be hindered. The lipid assemblies provide nanoscale confinement that makes crystallization more difficult under some conditions. The result is a change in how water behaves inside the material, not a general antifreeze effect that keeps a container of ordinary water liquid.
#1 Best Overall
The reported temperature of approximately 10 K—about −263 °C—refers to amorphous water maintained under nanoconfinement. “Amorphous” means the water lacks the regular crystalline structure of ice; it should not be described simply as liquid water at −263 °C.
Water content changes the outcome
The study’s results show why the finding cannot be generalized to every mixture. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) detected ice-melting peaks in DCPML samples containing 15%, 20% and 25% water, but not in samples containing 5% or 10% water. In a separate comparison at 7.5% water, the DCPML sample lacked the reported freezing-transition peak, while the ML comparison showed one near −8 °C. At 15% water, DCPML showed a transition near −9 °C.
Wide-angle X-ray scattering (WAXS) at −30 °C also showed different results at different hydration levels: the DCPML sample with 10% water lacked a crystalline ice pattern, while the sample with 25% water showed a pattern typical of hexagonal ice. The contrast makes water fraction and lipid phase central to interpreting the claim.
How the researchers examined the samples
The study used several methods to characterize the materials and water within them. DSC tracks thermal transitions, including ice melting; scattering techniques probe structure, while NMR provides information about molecular environments and dynamics. The authors also used molecular-dynamics simulations to help interpret the observed phase behavior.
Rank #3
- Differential scanning calorimetry: identified ice-melting or freezing-transition signals in samples with particular water fractions.
- Wide-angle X-ray scattering: distinguished samples showing crystalline ice patterns from those without such patterns under the reported conditions.
- Neutron scattering, NMR and SAXS: contributed to characterization of the lipid–water structures and their behavior.
- Molecular-dynamics simulations: supported interpretation of the phase behavior alongside experimental evidence.
What the finding does—and does not—show
The work offers a way to study how lipid structures interact with confined water, and the authors connect that understanding to questions about how organisms tolerate extreme cold. Chemistry World’s coverage likewise discusses this potential relevance. The study does not establish a biological treatment, a food-preservation method, a practical antifreeze product or a commercial technology. Its result is a materials and physical-chemistry finding about particular designed lipids and particular water contents.
Chemistry World’s 2019 report summarizes the proposed significance, while the experimental conditions and phase findings are detailed in the primary paper.
Quick Recap
Best Value
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
