CREDAI chairman Boman Irani called Mumbai “the mother of redevelopment models” at the 24th CREDAI NATCON in Kolkata, held October 2–4, 2026, and urged other cities to learn from its experience. The phrase is an industry leader’s assessment, not proof that Mumbai’s approach is better or can be transferred wholesale. The practical question is what other cities can learn—and what evidence they still need before copying it.
What CREDAI leaders said at NATCON
Irani told Hindustan Times: “Mumbai has consistently led the way; it is the mother of redevelopment models, and other cities should learn from the Mumbai model.” He presented Mumbai as an experienced example, rather than citing a comparative study showing that it produces better results.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
CREDAI president Shekhar Patel argued that redevelopment should be treated as more than a real-estate activity: “Redevelopment is not merely a real estate issue; it is a social requirement and an essential part of upgrading urban infrastructure. Governments should therefore focus on creating clear redevelopment policies for cities across the country.”
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Fix the driver behind crashes, sound loss and screen glitches2Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errors3Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteSushil Mohta, CREDAI West Bengal president, said Kolkata could learn from Mumbai’s experience and identify areas that might be redeveloped. The remarks make the case for considering redevelopment; they do not establish measured benefits for residents or infrastructure.
#1 Best Overall
Why Mumbai was held up as an example
Patel pointed to the length of Mumbai’s experience and offered figures from other cities as context. These are figures attributed to Patel in the Hindustan Times report, not independently verified statistics:
- Mumbai: Patel said its first redevelopment projects began nearly 30 years ago.
- Ahmedabad: He said more than 50 redevelopment projects were underway.
- Chennai: He said many homes were 50–60 years old.
- India’s urbanisation: Patel cited a forecast that about 60% of India would be urbanised by 2047.
The figures point to different reasons cities might consider redevelopment: an established track record, ongoing project activity, or ageing housing. They do not show that the cities share the same rules, needs, or project outcomes. The 2047 figure is Patel’s attributed forecast, not a verified projection here.
Rank #2
What the reported Maharashtra resolution would require
The Hindustan Times report describes a Maharashtra resolution dated September 30, 2026, with requirements concerning cooperative-society decisions, developer bids, and agreements. The official resolution text was not independently inspected, so the following is a report of what the newspaper says—not legal guidance or a substitute for checking the operative text, scope, and commencement.
- Society meeting and approval: The report says a two-thirds quorum is required and approval must come from at least 51% of the cooperative society’s total members. It also says members voting in favour must provide written consent.
- Remote participation: The report describes remote participation in specified cases but does not establish the full conditions in the resolution.
- Developer bids: At least three competitive bids are reported as required.
- Agreement deadlines: A Development Agreement is reported as due within three months, followed by a registered Permanent Alternative Accommodation Agreement within three months of registration of the Development Agreement.
These reported procedures may be relevant to resident participation and the selection of a developer, but their exact legal effect cannot be established from the newspaper summary alone. Residents or societies considering action should consult the official resolution and qualified local advice.
What other cities should assess before emulating Mumbai
“Learn from” need not mean “copy.” A city considering redevelopment needs to test how a proposed process fits its housing stock, institutions, and resident protections. The NATCON report does not provide comparative outcome data, so these are questions to investigate rather than conclusions about Mumbai’s model:
- Resident consent: Who is eligible to vote, how is consent recorded, and how are residents who cannot attend in person included?
- Developer selection: Is competition meaningful, and can residents assess bids on more than headline promises?
- Agreements and delivery: Are deadlines clear, and what happens if agreements or construction are delayed?
- Resident protection: What alternative accommodation is secured, on what terms, and when does the agreement protecting it take effect?
- Public outcomes: Does the project improve housing and infrastructure, and how are those outcomes measured against disruption and other costs?
Irani also raised a concern about a “two-year redevelopment provision,” according to the report, but it gives no detail about the provision or his concern. That remark cannot be used to infer what the rule does or why it is disputed.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.What the claim establishes—and what it does not
The report establishes that CREDAI’s national leadership is advocating wider use of redevelopment and presenting Mumbai as a source of experience. It also records a proposed policy direction in Maharashtra as summarized by Hindustan Times. It does not establish that Mumbai’s system is superior, that the reported requirements apply uniformly to all redevelopment, or that another city would achieve the same results by adopting them.
PC Slower Than It Used to Be?
A free scan shows the junk files, broken settings and background clutter dragging Windows down - then fixes them in one click.Free scan · Windows 10 & 11Outdated Drivers Are Slowing You Down
One free scan finds every outdated or missing driver and matches the right update for your exact hardware.Free scan · exact hardware matchAny serious comparison would need evidence on consent, developer competition, time to agreement and completion, alternative accommodation, and housing and infrastructure outcomes. Until those results are available, “mother of redevelopment models” is best read as advocacy—not an independently verified ranking.
Quick Recap
Source: Hindustan Times.
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
