Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Usually, leave HDR set to On When Supported rather than forcing it on. On PlayStation 5, that preserves the game’s native SDR output. The Always On option converts non-HDR games and apps, and the result can be excellent, merely different, or visibly wrong depending on your television’s tone mapping and calibration. Xbox Series X|S takes a more selective approach: Auto HDR enhances certain backward-compatible SDR games, but it is not applied to every title.
What “HDR on” actually means for an SDR game
Standard dynamic range (SDR) and high dynamic range (HDR) use different brightness and color targets. An SDR game authored for an SDR signal is not automatically improved when a console sends an HDR signal. The console has to convert the image, and the television or monitor then maps that signal to its own panel capabilities.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
That conversion can change peak highlights, black levels, mid-tone brightness, saturation and shadow detail. A display with careful tone mapping may produce a pleasing result. Another display may make the same game look washed out, too dark, overly vivid or artificially bright. There is no universal published statistic showing that forced HDR is better for all SDR console games, so the sensible default is to preserve native SDR unless your own comparison proves otherwise.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Outbyte PC Repair FREEClear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →PS5: use On When Supported as the baseline
Sony describes the two relevant PS5 choices directly:
#1 Best Overall
- 27” 240Hz 1500R Curved FHD 1080P Gaming Monitor for Game Play.
- Prioritizes Gaming Performance: Up to 240Hz high refresh rate, more immersive 1500R Curvature, FreeSync, MPRT 1ms Response Time, Black Level adjustment(shadow booster), Game Modes Preset, Crosshair.
- Cinematic Color Accuracy: 130% sRGB & DCI-P3 95% color gamut, 4000:1 contrast ratio, 300nits brightness, HDR, Anti-flicker; Anti-Glare.
- Plug & Play Design: HDMI & DP1.4 & Audio Jack(No built-in speakers), durable metal stand, tilt -5°~15, VESA 100*100mm compatible.
- Warranty: Money-back and free replacement within 30 days, 1-year quality warranty and lifetime technical support. Pls contact SANSUI service support first if any product problem.
- Always On: “If you select Always On, even games and apps that aren’t HDR-compatible automatically convert to HDR output.”
- On When Supported: “If you select On When Supported, games and apps that aren’t HDR-compatible display in SDR (standard dynamic range).”
For most players, select Settings > Screen and Video > Video Output > HDR > On When Supported. HDR-capable games can still use HDR, while non-HDR games remain in the format in which they were authored.
When PS5 Always On can be worth trying
Always On is a display-preference option, not a quality upgrade. It can suit you if you prefer the converted game’s overall brightness or color and your display handles the signal naturally. Test it with the same game, the same scene and the same television picture preset. Keep it only if you prefer the result without clipped bright areas, gray or raised blacks, crushed shadow detail, excessive saturation or an unnaturally bright image.
Do not judge from the console menu alone. Menus often have different graphics and brightness behavior from the game engine. Compare a bright outdoor scene, a dark interior and an area containing small bright details such as lamps, reflections or stars.
Rank #2
- BOOST YOUR REALITY: Your gaming world, more lifelike than ever. With 1.7x the pixel density of Full HD, QHD resolution offers razor-sharp, highly detailed visuals. Experience a wider view with more space to immerse yourself in every moment of action
- REACT IN REAL TIME: Experience the exhilaration of gameplay as you speed through scenes with a 165Hz refresh rate that eliminates lag for smooth action; Jump on enemies immediately with a 1ms1 response time (MPRT) for frames with minimal blur¹
- EXHILARATE YOUR SENSES: Experience the next level of heart-pounding gaming; Vivid scenes wrap even more tightly around you with the 1000R curved display, filling your peripheral vision and drawing you right into the character's shoes
- STAY IN SYNC WITH ALL THE ACTION: AMD Radeon FreeSync keeps your monitor and graphics card refresh rate in sync to reduce image tearing, providing a superfluid entertainment experience. Watch movies and play games without interruptions
- FIND HIDDEN DETAILS OTHERS MISS: Awe-inspiring graphics with HDR10; A kaleidoscope of shades brings game scenes to life with incredible vibrancy; Uncover secrets hiding in the shadows with deep dark blacks, luminous whites & detailed resolution
Xbox Series X|S: Auto HDR is selective
Xbox says that “Auto HDR automatically enhances SDR games that pre-date HDR technology, enabling them to deliver brighter, more colourful worlds.” On Xbox Series X|S, this is not the same as forcing every SDR frame through a generic conversion. Auto HDR is enabled only for supported backward-compatible titles, and the result varies by game.
Leave the console’s HDR capability available if you play older supported games and like the enhancement. A title that receives Auto HDR may show brighter highlights and more saturated colors than its original SDR presentation. An SDR title that is not supported remains SDR, so the setting is not a promise that every older game will change.
How to tell whether Auto HDR is active
Start the game and watch for the console’s HDR notification or consult the game’s backward-compatibility information. If one title changes while another does not, that is expected behavior. Compare each game independently rather than assuming that an Xbox-wide setting produces the same image everywhere.
Rank #3
- Samsung’s 32” Odyssey G5 QHD Gaming Monitor delivers brilliant visuals for exhilarating gameplay that’s more immersive than ever before.
- QHD resolution (2560 x 1440) boasts incredibly detailed, pin-sharp images.
- With a wide 178° viewing angle, the IPS panel consistently delivers crisp, clear hues from various viewpoints.
- 180Hz Refresh Rate and 1ms response time (GtG) allow fast reactions for ultra-smooth gaming, plus G-Sync compatibility syncs the GPU and panel to reduce choppiness, screen lag, and image tearing.
- HDR10 provides brighter highlights and nuanced shadows for added depth.
Why two displays can produce opposite results
The console output is only one part of the chain. Microsoft’s Advanced Color documentation defines SDR reference white as the brightness at which diffuse white appears within an HDR scene and notes that desktop HDR monitors are typically set around 200 nits (Microsoft, 2022). Displays also use tone mapping to compress HDR luminance and color into the range their panels can reproduce.
What’s actually slowing this PC down?
Pick the symptom - the matching free tool is one click away.
Those choices explain why a converted SDR game can look balanced on one television and pale or overly dim on another. A television may use a separate picture preset for HDR input, alter its local-dimming behavior, or apply dynamic contrast when it detects HDR. Console calibration sliders cannot compensate for every television processing decision.
Picture settings that make a fair comparison
- Use the same HDMI input and viewing mode for both tests.
- Disable aggressive dynamic contrast, “vivid” color modes and automatic brightness enhancements while comparing.
- If the display supports separate SDR and HDR presets, configure each deliberately instead of copying settings between them.
- Allow the television to finish switching formats before judging brightness; some displays take a moment to load the HDR preset.
- Compare real gameplay, including a known-dark scene, rather than relying on a paused frame or a console dashboard.
Native SDR versus forced or automatic HDR
| Comparison point | Native SDR output | Forced or automatic HDR |
|---|---|---|
| Accuracy to the game’s original mastering | Highest on an SDR-authored title | Depends on the conversion and display tone mapping |
| Highlights and bright effects | Remain within the SDR range authored by the developer | May appear brighter, but can clip fine detail |
| Shadows and black level | Usually predictable when the display’s SDR mode is calibrated | Can become lifted, crushed or inconsistent |
| Color and skin-tone neutrality | Uses the game’s intended SDR color relationships | May look richer, but excessive saturation is possible |
| Compatibility | Works for every SDR game | PS5 Always On converts broadly; Xbox Auto HDR applies only to supported titles |
| Calibration effort | One SDR setup is generally sufficient | May require separate SDR and HDR presets and a second calibration |
How to choose the right setting
- Identify the game’s native format. Check whether the title has an HDR option or is known to receive Xbox Auto HDR. Do not assume that an older game supports HDR merely because the console is connected to an HDR television.
- Set a neutral baseline. On PS5, choose On When Supported. On Xbox, leave HDR capability available, then evaluate supported Auto HDR titles individually.
- Calibrate HDR after changing display modes. On PS5, use Settings > Screen and Video > Video Output > Adjust HDR after selecting the television’s HDR picture mode. On Xbox, use the console’s HDR calibration tool from the display settings.
- Compare an identical scene. Record your impression of highlight detail, shadow detail, black level, mid-tone brightness, color neutrality and eye strain. Switch only one setting at a time.
- Check the display preset. Confirm that the television has not switched to a “Dynamic,” “Game HDR” or other high-brightness mode that changes the comparison independently of the console.
- Keep the setting that preserves detail. A brighter picture is not automatically more accurate. If bright clouds lose texture, dark areas merge into black or neutral colors become neon, return to native SDR.
Why SDR games can look washed out with HDR enabled
A washed-out image usually indicates a mismatch between the signal and the display’s picture processing rather than a defect in the game. Common causes include an HDR preset with an incorrect black level, a tone-mapping curve that raises mid-tones, a console calibration performed before the television mode changed, or dynamic processing that is active only for HDR input.
Rank #4
- 27-inch 4K Ultra HD Display: Features 3840 x 2160 resolution gaming monitor with ultra-fast 160Hz refresh rate designed for professional gamers and immersive gameplay
- ASUS Extreme Low Motion Blur Sync Technology: ELMB Sync technology enables ELMB and variable-refresh-rate technologies to work simultaneously to eliminate ghosting and tearing for sharp gaming visuals with high frame rates
- Advanced Synchronization Technologies: NVIDIA G-SYNC Compatible, AMD FreeSync Premium, and exclusive Variable Overdrive technology ensure seamless, tear-free gaming experience
- Superior Color Performance: High dynamic range (HDR) technology and 95% DCI-P3 professional color gamut provide amazing color accuracy and vibrant visuals
- Package Contents: Includes DisplayPort cable, L-shaped Screwdriver, Power cord, Quick start guide, and Warranty Card
Correct the mismatch
- On PS5, switch from Always On to On When Supported and check whether the game returns to its normal SDR appearance.
- Re-run HDR calibration after selecting the intended HDR picture preset.
- Verify that the television’s black-level setting matches the console’s range; an incorrect limited/full-range pairing can produce gray blacks or crushed shadows.
- Turn off dynamic contrast and exaggerated color enhancement while diagnosing the problem.
- Use the game’s own brightness or paper-white control only after the console and television signal levels are correct.
Troubleshooting obvious failures
Microsoft’s XR-131 guidance treats several symptoms as failure conditions rather than normal differences. These include an SDR image that is significantly lighter or darker than the HDR image, a smaller image, black bars or other obvious defects after changing output modes.
If the image becomes much lighter or darker
- Return to native SDR on PS5 by selecting On When Supported.
- Check the television’s input-specific picture mode and brightness controls.
- Confirm that no energy-saving or ambient-light mode has altered the panel brightness.
- Re-run the console’s HDR calibration only after the display mode is stable.
If borders or a smaller picture appear
Check the television’s aspect-ratio, overscan and “screen fit” controls. A format switch should not create permanent black bars around a game image. If the defect occurs only in forced HDR, keep the game in native SDR and investigate the display’s HDR handling or firmware.
Recommended Free Tools
If dark detail disappears
Use a dark in-game scene with visible texture, not a black test screen. Lowering an HDR slider may hide the symptom while clipping detail elsewhere. If shadow information remains crushed after calibration, native SDR is the safer presentation for that title.
Best Value
- 32 Inch curved 1500R gaming monitor, 240Hz high refresh rate for gameplay
- Performance: 240Hz refresh rate, Full HD 1920*1080P resolution, 1ms MPRT response time, Built-in FreeSync technology, Anti-flicker, Low blue light
- Interfaces: HDMI up to 240Hz, DP 1.4 up to 240Hz, Earphone Jack, No speakers built-in. One DP cable comes with the package
- Display Colors: 125% sRGB color gamut, 16.7M display colors, 300 Nits brightness, HDR technology, 3500:1 contrast
- Ergonomic Design: 1500R curved, Tilt: -5°~15°, VESA Compatible (100 x 100mm), 178° Wide Viewing Angle.Recommended distance of playing games in this monitor is about 1.2 meters.
Separate brightness controls matter
Many televisions store SDR and HDR brightness, local-dimming and gamma values separately. A brightness value that looks correct for HDR can make an SDR game look gray or dim, and an SDR setting copied into HDR can clip highlights. Adjust each mode while it is active, then recheck the same game scene after the television switches formats.
For a neutral setup, use the display’s game mode, select a sensible color temperature rather than a cool blue preset, and avoid processing that changes brightness scene by scene. The goal is consistent detail and natural color, not the highest numerical brightness.
A practical decision rule
- Choose PS5 On When Supported when you want the most predictable, native result or when forced HDR introduces washed-out colors, gray blacks, clipped highlights or eye strain.
- Try PS5 Always On only when a specific game looks better to you after a controlled comparison and calibration.
- Keep Xbox HDR available if you play backward-compatible games that support Auto HDR and prefer their enhanced presentation.
- Use native SDR whenever an SDR title shows obvious defects, regardless of whether another game benefits from HDR conversion.
The best setting is therefore game- and display-dependent, but the reliable starting point is clear: preserve SDR on PS5 with On When Supported, and treat Xbox Auto HDR as a selective enhancement rather than a universal requirement.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
