Free tools Windows power users keep installed
One-click scans. No signup required.
Iron and cobalt can replace precious-metal catalysts in some hydrogenation reactions, but the 2013 results behind this headline do not establish a universal substitute. Three separate studies demonstrated useful performance in narrowly defined settings: an iron complex for asymmetric transfer hydrogenation, a cobalt system for asymmetric alkene hydrogenation with hydrogen gas, and iron-oxide nanoparticles for selective nitroarene reduction. Their substrates, catalyst formats and operating conditions differ substantially, so each result must be judged on its own chemistry.
What “base-metal catalysts” means in hydrogenation
Hydrogenation adds hydrogen to an unsaturated chemical bond. In industrial and laboratory synthesis, catalysts make that addition fast and selective enough to be useful. Precious metals such as ruthenium, rhodium, palladium, platinum and iridium have dominated many hydrogenation processes because their electronic structures support demanding bond-making and bond-breaking steps. Iron and cobalt are more abundant transition metals and are generally attractive when a process can obtain comparable selectivity and productivity without relying on scarce elements.
| # | Preview | Product | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |
|
Iron and Cobalt Catalysts | $82.61 | Buy on Amazon |
| 2 |
|
LEXIVON Butane Torch Head & Catalyst Replacement | Fits LX-770 & LX-771 | $9.97 | Buy on Amazon |
| 3 |
|
Iron Catalyst | $1.29 | Buy on Amazon |
| 4 |
|
Build a Custom TaylorMade Qi HL Iron, #5, Catalyst Black Ladies | $119.99 | Buy on Amazon |
| 5 |
|
LEXIVON 2-Piece Butane Torch Head & Solder Tip Set | Fits LX-770/771 | $12.97 | Buy on Amazon |
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
The phrase “base metal” in this context does not mean an unreactive or low-performance material. It means a relatively abundant transition metal used instead of a precious metal. Performance still depends on the metal’s oxidation state, ligand environment, solvent, hydrogen source, pressure, temperature and substrate. A catalyst that is excellent for one reaction may be ineffective, unstable or insufficiently selective for another.
Outdated Drivers Are Slowing You Down
One free scan finds every outdated or missing driver and matches the right update for your exact hardware.Free scan · exact hardware matchWindows Errors? Fix Them Before They Spread
Repair common Windows errors and clear accumulated junk for a smoother, more stable PC - no reinstall needed.Free scan · no reinstallThe attention-grabbing 2013 Chemistry World report, “Base metal catalysts strike hydrogenation gold,” described three contemporaneous efforts. Together they support a precise conclusion: abundant metals can deliver high activity or selectivity for selected transformations when their surrounding chemistry is engineered carefully. They do not prove that iron or cobalt can replace precious metals across hydrogenation chemistry.
#1 Best Overall
Three different demonstrations, not one universal catalyst
| Study and catalyst form | Reaction class | Hydrogen source and conditions | Reported outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Iron amine(imine)diphosphine complexes; homogeneous | Asymmetric transfer hydrogenation of ketones and imines | Isopropanol served as solvent and hydrogen donor; some reactions ran at room temperature and pressure | Direct preparation of the active species gave a reported 30-fold activity increase; some reactions finished in seconds |
| Cobalt salts with bisphosphine ligands and organometallic activators; homogeneous | Asymmetric hydrogenation of an alkene, initially methyl 2-acetamidoacrylate | Hydrogen gas at room temperature and 3.4 MPa in the initial screening | Selected combinations gave yields and enantiomeric excesses above 90%; screening also found a catalyst for an unfunctionalized alkene |
| Iron-oxide-based nanoparticles; heterogeneous | Selective reduction of aromatic nitro groups to anilines | Hydrogen gas at 5 MPa and 120°C | Reported examples left ketones, amides and nitriles unaffected while reducing the nitro group |
The table makes the central limitation visible. The first iron system transfers hydrogen from isopropanol in solution under mild conditions. The cobalt system uses compressed hydrogen and a designed ligand/activator combination. The nanoparticle process is a heterogeneous reaction at substantially higher pressure and temperature. Calling all three simply “iron or cobalt hydrogenation” hides the engineering that makes each one work.
Iron transfer hydrogenation: activity came from controlling the active species
What the Zuo team studied
W. Zuo and colleagues developed amine(imine)diphosphine iron catalysts for asymmetric transfer hydrogenation. In this reaction mode, the reactor does not need a separate cylinder of hydrogen gas. Isopropanol supplies hydrogen while also acting as the solvent. Ketones and imines are reduced to more saturated products, and the chiral catalyst environment is intended to favor one enantiomer over the other.
The Chemistry World account says that isopropanol reduced an imine group in one ligand, generating the active catalyst species during the reaction. That observation changed how the catalyst was prepared. Producing the active species directly rather than waiting for it to form in situ produced a reported 30-fold increase in activity for the particular system. Some reactions were completed in seconds at room temperature and pressure.
Why the result matters
The striking number is not a general “iron is 30 times faster” claim. It measures the difference between two preparation pathways for the reported catalyst chemistry. The lesson is mechanistic: catalyst activation can determine practical performance as much as the identity of the metal. An iron complex that appears slow may be spending time converting into its true active form; isolating or generating that form deliberately can remove the delay.
The mild operating conditions are also specific to transfer hydrogenation. Isopropanol is a reagent and solvent that must be separated from the product stream or managed in solvent recovery. The method therefore trades compressed hydrogen for a sacrificial hydrogen donor and the associated by-products. Whether that trade is favorable depends on the substrate, scale, solvent-recovery equipment and product specification.
Rank #2
- Use for electronic wire soldering, decorative wood burning, hot insulation shrinking and many other applications
- Head / Catalyst is also compatible with power probe ppsk; Head / Catalyst is NOT compatible with dremel-versa series
- Head / Catalyst is also compatible with power probe ppsk
What is and is not established
The University of Toronto Morris Group lists the Science paper and describes its continuing focus on iron catalysts and ligand design for green chemistry and homogeneous catalysis. The reported seconds-scale reactions demonstrate that an iron complex can be highly active in selected asymmetric reductions. They do not establish equal performance for every ketone or imine, nor do they show that transfer hydrogenation can replace all gas-phase hydrogenation processes.
Cobalt hydrogenation: high selectivity required a large screening effort
The initial experiment
Paul Chirik’s Princeton group, working with Merck scientists, used high-throughput screening to search for cobalt catalysts capable of asymmetric alkene hydrogenation. Their initial campaign tested 192 bisphosphine ligands with cobalt salts against methyl 2-acetamidoacrylate. The reactions were run at room temperature under 3.4 MPa hydrogen, a pressure far above atmospheric pressure even though the temperature was mild.
The Tool Desk
Outbyte PC Repair FREEClear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsFree Scan →Outbyte Driver Updater FREEScan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minuteDriver Scan →Screening that many ligand combinations reflects a practical reality of base-metal catalysis: changing the ligand can alter oxidation state, geometry, hydrogen activation, substrate binding and the pathway by which the product leaves the catalyst. Cobalt alone does not predict the outcome. The metal salt, ligand, additives and activation sequence form one catalytic system.
Role of activators and measured performance
Organometallic activators expanded the combinations that worked. For selected catalyst combinations, the report describes yields above 90% and enantiomeric excesses above 90%. Yield indicates how much starting material became the desired product; enantiomeric excess indicates the preference for one mirror-image product over the other. Achieving both numbers in the same reaction is important for pharmaceuticals and other applications where the unwanted enantiomer may have different properties.
The screening strategy also identified catalysts for an unfunctionalized alkene substrate. That finding broadened the significance beyond the original, more highly functionalized test molecule, but it still does not define a universal substrate scope. The successful combinations were discovered empirically and depended on the screened ligand and activator set.
Rank #3
Why rapid screening is part of the chemistry
Chirik summarized the approach this way: “If you’re serious about doing this with cobalt or iron, you’ve got to screen ligands rapidly.” The statement is a process requirement, not a marketing slogan. Precious-metal catalysts often benefit from mature ligand families and extensive historical optimization. Base-metal systems can access different reaction pathways, including unwanted radical or redox chemistry, so a broad and systematic search may be necessary to find a narrow high-performing window.
Iron-oxide nanoparticles: selective nitroarene reduction at harsher conditions
Reaction and catalyst format
A team led by Matthias Beller used iron-oxide-based nanoparticles in a heterogeneous hydrogenation. Instead of a soluble molecular complex, the catalyst is a solid dispersed through the reaction mixture. The reported target was selective conversion of aromatic nitro groups to anilines, an important transformation in the preparation of dyes, agrochemicals, medicines and functional materials.
The reported conditions were 5 MPa hydrogen and 120°C. Those conditions are substantially more demanding than the room-temperature iron transfer-hydrogenation examples. They require equipment rated for compressed hydrogen and elevated temperature, along with procedures for gas handling, heat control, catalyst recovery and filtration.
Chemoselectivity in multifunctional molecules
In the examples described by Chemistry World, ketones, amides and nitriles remained unaffected while the aromatic nitro group was reduced. This chemoselectivity is valuable because a molecule can contain several groups that might be reducible under hydrogenation conditions. Preserving the other groups avoids protecting-group steps, limits by-products and can simplify purification.
“Selective” does not mean every substrate behaves identically. Particle size, support properties, solvent, hydrogen mass transfer and impurities can all change a heterogeneous reaction. The reported examples establish a useful pattern for the studied substrates; they do not guarantee that every nitroarene will leave every ketone, amide or nitrile untouched.
Rank #4
- Choose Iron, Shaft and Flex From Drop Down Menu.
- Shaft Options: Project X Catalyst Black (Graphite) or TRUE TEMPER XP85 (Steel).
- TRUE TEMPER Icon Standard Grip.
Can iron or cobalt replace precious metals?
The defensible answer is “sometimes, for a defined reaction,” not “yes, in hydrogenation generally.” Replacement requires matching several criteria at once:
- Reaction fit: The catalyst must reduce the intended bond without damaging other functional groups.
- Selectivity: For chiral products, enantiomeric excess must meet the process specification, not merely exceed a headline value in one example.
- Productivity: Activity, catalyst loading, reaction time and catalyst lifetime determine whether a laboratory result can support a manufacturing cycle.
- Operating envelope: Hydrogen pressure, temperature, solvent, activators and feed purity must be compatible with available equipment and safety controls.
- Work-up and metal control: A soluble iron or cobalt complex and a recoverable nanoparticle pose different separation and residual-metal questions.
- Reproducibility: Ligand preparation, catalyst activation and particle properties must be controlled from batch to batch.
The three 2013 studies meet some of these tests in their own niches. The iron transfer-hydrogenation system offers rapid reactions under mild temperature and pressure but consumes isopropanol as the hydrogen donor. The cobalt system reaches high reported yield and enantioselectivity in selected combinations but relies on extensive ligand screening, organometallic activation and compressed hydrogen. The nanoparticle system offers chemoselective nitro reduction but operates at 120°C and 5 MPa.
Independent reader supportYour contribution helps us test, update, and keep practical guides available for everyone.Why abundant metals attracted industrial and energy interest
Iron and cobalt are more abundant than many precious metals. That can motivate substitution for two distinct reasons. First, a catalyst containing an abundant element may reduce exposure to supply constraints and the material cost of the metal itself. Second, pharmaceutical manufacturers may prefer catalyst systems that make residual-metal control easier, although the acceptable limit still depends on the specific element, product and regulatory framework.
Robert Morris captured the motivation in the Chemistry World report: “So we really have to use the abundant elements instead of rare ones.” The statement expresses a strategic direction, not a quantified lifecycle assessment. The same report quoted a comparison in which ruthenium was described as “10,000 times more expensive,” but it did not define the date, market basis or calculation method. That figure should not be treated as a current price statistic.
The potential reach extends beyond organic synthesis. Morris Bullock of Pacific Northwest National Laboratory said: “The concepts are equally applicable to energy-related catalytic reactions. The need to examine the reactivity that can be obtained from abundant metals is pervasive through all catalytic applications.” Energy relevance is a rationale for continued catalyst development, not evidence that these particular laboratory systems are deployed in energy technology.
Best Value
- Interchangeable Tips for LEXIVON Butane Torches - The LX-770 Soldering Iron and the LX-771 Soldering Torch.
- Set includes Head/Catalyst & Standard Solder Tip.
- Use for electronic wire soldering, decorative wood burning, hot insulation shrinking and many other applications.
- Tip threads are also compatible with: dremel versatip 2000, versaflame 2200 and power probe ppsk.
- Head / Catalyst is also compatible with power probe ppsk. Head / Catalyst is NOT compatible with dremel-versa series.
Practical decision framework for choosing a catalyst class
Choose transfer hydrogenation when gas handling is the main constraint
If a ketone or imine can tolerate isopropanol and the resulting solvent/by-products are manageable, an iron transfer-hydrogenation system may avoid a hydrogen-gas feed. Confirm the substrate scope, chiral selectivity and catalyst activation protocol for the exact iron complex. The 30-fold activity improvement came from direct preparation of the active species in the reported system, so reproducing the preparation sequence is part of reproducing the result.
Choose a cobalt hydrogenation platform when enantioselective alkene reduction is required
For an alkene such as methyl 2-acetamidoacrylate, a cobalt/bisphosphine platform can be screened for both conversion and enantioselectivity. Plan for high-throughput experimentation and possible organometallic activators rather than assuming that a commercially familiar ligand will work. The initial reported pressure was 3.4 MPa hydrogen at room temperature; reactor certification and hydrogen-safety procedures are therefore essential.
Choose a heterogeneous iron system when catalyst separation and chemoselectivity dominate
For nitroarene-to-aniline chemistry, iron-oxide nanoparticles offer a solid catalyst format and reported preservation of ketones, amides and nitriles in selected examples. Evaluate filtration, nanoparticle retention, metal leaching and catalyst reuse alongside conversion. The 5 MPa hydrogen and 120°C conditions set a very different equipment and energy requirement from the homogeneous iron examples.
Do these 3 things before closing this tab:
1Repair Windows errors before they cause bigger problems2Scan for outdated or missing drivers - takes under a minute3Clear out junk files and repair common Windows errorsLimitations readers should keep in view
- The detailed performance figures come from the contemporaneous Chemistry World account of the studies. The primary Science pages were not available for direct checking in the material used here.
- The studies are demonstrations for particular substrates and catalyst formulations, not head-to-head trials proving that base metals outperform precious metals across a common panel.
- Current industrial adoption, present-day catalyst availability and modern metal-price comparisons are not established by these reports.
- “Above 90%” yield and enantiomeric excess describe selected cobalt combinations; they are not average values for cobalt catalysts.
- The iron nanoparticle conditions of 5 MPa and 120°C should not be conflated with the mild, solvent-based iron transfer-hydrogenation conditions.
A specialist reference for readers who need broader practical coverage is Handbook of Heterogeneous Catalytic Hydrogenation for Organic Synthesis, cited in a 2018 Royal Society of Chemistry bibliography. The citation makes it relevant further reading, but it does not establish current retail availability or endorse a particular catalyst, reactor or reagent.
What the 2013 results changed
These studies shifted the question from whether iron or cobalt can participate in hydrogenation to how their reactivity can be engineered. The iron work showed that identifying the true active species can transform rate. The cobalt work showed that ligand and activator discovery can turn a broad combinatorial search into high asymmetric performance. The nanoparticle work showed that an abundant-metal solid can distinguish a nitro group from other reducible functionalities under hydrogen pressure.
That is why the headline’s “gold” is best read as a milestone in catalyst design rather than a declaration that precious metals are obsolete. Base-metal catalysts are credible alternatives when the reaction, ligand or particle architecture and process conditions are matched carefully. Broad replacement will require additional substrate coverage, durability data, separation studies, safety analysis and scale-up evidence for each application.
Quick Recap
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon at the time of purchase will apply.
