FREEDOM251

Freedom251 › Compare

Side by side

Prefail vs Scrutiny

Both stand on disk health monitoring software. Which one you can start free with, which one lets you read the code, and what each costs once you pay.

Prefail

Free plan APILinux

Choose Prefail if you need S.M.A.R.T.-based disk monitoring, alerts, and fleet reporting for Linux servers. Look elsewhere if you need protection against sudden electrical or controller failures; Prefail explicitly says monitoring does not replace backups.

Visit Prefail

Scrutiny

Free plan APILinuxMac+3

Scrutiny provides self-hosted S.M.A.R.T. monitoring with several deployment and alerting options. Check hardware compatibility and permission requirements before choosing a deployment method.

Visit Scrutiny

The facts

PrefailScrutiny
Free planYesYes
Open sourceNot publishedNot published
Runs onAPI, LinuxAPI, Linux, Mac, Self-hosted, Web, Windows
Lowest paid planPRO: $9 a monthFree or on request
Plans published51
MakerNot publishedNot published
Websiteprefail.iogithub.com
On disk health monitoring software#16 of 30#12 of 30

Prefail: what it does well

  • Scores each disk using 25+ S.M.A.R.T. attributes.
  • Shows seven-day score deltas and stable or rising signals.
  • Supports individual disk health behind supported RAID controllers.
  • Provides Telegram alerts, dashboard, and email fallback.
  • Sends a weekly PDF fleet report.

What to know first

  • The free plan covers up to 2 servers.
  • S.M.A.R.T. cannot warn about some sudden failures.
  • Prefail says it is not a substitute for backups.

Scrutiny: what it does well

  • Free and MIT licensed
  • Tracks S.M.A.R.T. history and temperature
  • Supports customizable failure thresholds
  • Offers multiple alert destinations

What to know first

  • Docker requires drive passthrough and SYS_RAWIO
  • NVMe drives may also require SYS_ADMIN
  • Some RAID controllers do not expose SMART data
  • Project notes it has rough edges

Alternatives to Prefail Alternatives to Scrutiny The whole list