FREEDOM251

Freedom251 › Compare

Side by side

Payroll Mate vs QuickBooks Payroll

Both stand on church payroll software. Which one you can start free with, which one lets you read the code, and what each costs once you pay.

Payroll Mate

Free trial Windows

Payroll Mate covers in-house payroll calculations, federal forms, reporting, and accounting exports in a Windows desktop package. Budget separately for add-ons if you need direct deposit, MICR printing, state forms, or vendor management.

Visit Payroll Mate

QuickBooks Payroll

Free trial AndroidiPhoneWeb
Visit QuickBooks Payroll

The facts

Payroll MateQuickBooks Payroll
Free planA free trialA free trial
Open sourceNot publishedNot published
Runs onWindowsAndroid, iPhone, Web
Lowest paid planPayroll Mate: $219 a yearWorkforce Payroll: $15 a month
Plans published13
MakerNot publishedNot published
Websitepayroll.payrollmate.comquickbooks.intuit.com
On church payroll software#17 of 27#13 of 27

Payroll Mate: what it does well

  • Calculates federal and state payroll taxes
  • Prepares listed federal payroll forms
  • Exports reports in four file formats
  • Exports data to major accounting programs
  • Includes a free 30-day trial

What to know first

  • Costs $219 a year
  • Direct deposit requires a paid add-on
  • Several payroll functions require paid add-ons
  • Mac use requires Parallels Desktop or VMware

QuickBooks Payroll: what it does well

    Alternatives to Payroll Mate Alternatives to QuickBooks Payroll The whole list