FREEDOM251

Freedom251 › Compare

Side by side

Milkie vs Paperwall

Both stand on paywall software. Which one you can start free with, which one lets you read the code, and what each costs once you pay.

Milkie

Free plan Web

Milkie provides subscription and sign-in gates for Next.js, with metered access and configurable presentation. Developers should account for its three-route setup and roadmap gaps when planning an implementation.

Visit Milkie

Paperwall

Free plan ExtensionSelf-hostedWeb

Paperwall offers per-article payments alongside tools for publishers, readers, and developers. Manual funding and the unfinished publisher controls are relevant limitations to consider.

Visit Paperwall

The facts

MilkiePaperwall
Free planYesYes
Open sourceNot publishedNot published
Runs onWebExtension, Self-hosted, Web
Lowest paid planFree or on requestSubscription: $10 a month
Plans published12
MakerNot publishedNot published
Websitemilkie.devpaperwall.app
On paywall software#9 of 30#5 of 30

Milkie: what it does well

  • Free and MIT licensed
  • Gates pages, sections, or individual components
  • Supports metered monthly free access
  • Integrates with several named authentication providers
  • Lists multiple built-in security protections

What to know first

  • Requires creating three API routes
  • Uses Stripe hosted checkout
  • One-time payments are not supported
  • Several capabilities remain roadmap items

Paperwall: what it does well

  • Publishers can enable payments with one script tag
  • Encrypted reader wallet is stored on the device
  • Developer tools are free to use or self-host
  • GPL-3.0 licensing allows forking and self-hosting

What to know first

  • Accounts currently require manual funding
  • Publisher allowlists and denylists remain in development
  • Firefox and Safari are on the roadmap, not supported currently
  • Server mode requires a backend

Alternatives to Milkie Alternatives to Paperwall The whole list