FREEDOM251

Freedom251 › Compare

Side by side

MasterTax vs ModernEFile Mate

Both stand on payroll tax software. Which one you can start free with, which one lets you read the code, and what each costs once you pay.

MasterTax

Paid APIWeb

Choose MasterTax if your organization needs to schedule, pay, file, and report payroll taxes across jurisdictions, with implementation and ongoing support. Contact the maker for pricing and a demo before deciding whether its configuration fits your operation.

Visit MasterTax

ModernEFile Mate

Free trial Windows

ModernEFile Mate focuses on federal Forms 941 and 940, with local storage and filing-oriented tools. Check the company limit, single-computer license, and manual submission process before choosing a plan.

Visit ModernEFile Mate

The facts

MasterTaxModernEFile Mate
Free planNot publishedA free trial
Open sourceNot publishedNot published
Runs onAPI, WebWindows
Lowest paid planFree or on request10 companies: $245 a year
Plans published15
MakerMasterTaxNot published
Websitemastertax.comrealtaxtools.com
On payroll tax software#21 of 31#17 of 31

MasterTax: what it does well

  • Covers more than 11,000 U.S. payroll tax jurisdictions.
  • Creates original and amended returns in multiple formats.
  • Offers APIs for file import, retrieval, and data extracts.
  • Includes agency notice management and customizable reporting.
  • Dedicated implementation specialist supports migration and setup.

What to know first

  • Pricing is available on request.

ModernEFile Mate: what it does well

  • Prepares Forms 941 and 940
  • Stores data locally without cloud storage
  • Built-in validation and PDF preview
  • Supports two PIN signing methods
  • Includes filing status tracking and backups

What to know first

  • Windows 10 or 11 only
  • Manual IRS upload is required
  • No free plan
  • Trial cannot create e-file submissions

Alternatives to MasterTax Alternatives to ModernEFile Mate The whole list