Side by side
Shinken vs SmokePing
Both stand on network monitoring. Which one you can start free with, which one lets you read the code, and what each costs once you pay.
Free plan LinuxSelf-hostedWindows
Shinken provides a scalable, self-hosted monitoring framework with Nagios compatibility and distributed daemons. Its main limitation is that check plugins must be obtained separately or created.
Visit Shinken Free plan LinuxSelf-hostedWeb
SmokePing provides detailed latency and packet-loss monitoring, with graph navigation, configurable alarms, and distributed measurement options. It requires a self-hosted Unix setup and several software prerequisites.
Visit SmokePingThe facts
| Shinken | SmokePing | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes | Yes |
| Open source | Not published | Not published |
| Runs on | Linux, Self-hosted, Windows | Linux, Self-hosted, Web |
| Lowest paid plan | Not published | Free or on request |
| Plans published | None | 1 |
| Maker | Not published | Not published |
| Website | shinken-monitoring.org | oss.oetiker.ch |
| On network monitoring | #29 of 55 | #25 of 55 |
Shinken: what it does well
- Free under the GNU Affero General Public License
- Reuses Nagios configurations and plugins
- Daemon architecture supports load distribution
- Spare daemons provide high availability
- Supports broad monitoring protocols and packs
What to know first
- Check plugins are not included
- Requires self-hosted installation
- Configuration and setup are user-managed
- Support uses a GitHub issue list
SmokePing: what it does well
- Stores long-term data and generates graphs with RRDtool.
- Includes probes for DNS, LDAP, SSH, HTTP, HTTPS, and TCP ping.
- Alarms can trigger on configurable latency patterns.
- Master/slave setup measures from multiple sources.
- Supports plug-in probes, alarms, and charting.
What to know first
- Installation requires Unix, Perl, RRDtool, and FPing.
- Web interface requires a CGI-capable web server.
- Exposing ARGV to the web server can create a security vulnerability.
Alternatives to Shinken Alternatives to SmokePing The whole list