FREEDOM251

Freedom251 › Compare

Side by side

Roslynator vs Spoon

Both stand on code refactoring tools. Which one you can start free with, which one lets you read the code, and what each costs once you pay.

Roslynator

Free plan ExtensionLinuxMac+1

Roslynator offers IDE, command-line, and testing tools for code analysis and refactoring, with analyzers distributed separately. Check the editor requirements and supported security versions before choosing an extension.

Visit Roslynator

Spoon

Free plan APILinuxSelf-hosted

Spoon brings Java parsing, analysis, and transformation into one library, with documented support for workflows from refactoring to CI architecture checks. Check the JDK requirement for the release you plan to run, and account for manual classpath setup if using the command line.

Visit Spoon

The facts

RoslynatorSpoon
Free planYesYes
Open sourceNot publishedNot published
Runs onExtension, Linux, Mac, WindowsAPI, Linux, Self-hosted
Lowest paid planFree or on requestFree or on request
Plans published11
MakerNot publishedNot published
Websitegithub.comspoon.gforge.inria.fr
On code refactoring tools#11 of 22#15 of 22

Roslynator: what it does well

  • Free and open source under Apache License 2.0
  • IDE refactorings and compiler-diagnostic fixes
  • CLI integrates with MegaLinter for CI
  • EditorConfig can configure analyzers and fixes

What to know first

  • Analyzers are separate NuGet packages
  • VS Code requires legacy OmniSharp
  • VS Code extension does not work with C# Dev Kit
  • Visual Studio 2022 extensions are out of security support

Spoon: what it does well

  • Supports source-level static analysis with AST processors
  • Can express architectural rules as JUnit tests
  • Includes refactoring and instrumentation capabilities
  • Works with Java, Maven, Gradle, and the command line

What to know first

  • Runtime JDK requirements vary by Spoon release
  • Command-line users must manage the classpath manually

Alternatives to Roslynator Alternatives to Spoon The whole list