FREEDOM251

Freedom251 › Compare

Side by side

Pelmet vs Vanilla

Both stand on menu bar customization software. Which one you can start free with, which one lets you read the code, and what each costs once you pay.

Pelmet

Free plan Mac

Pelmet offers several ways to sort and reveal menu bar icons, along with replacement items and app launchers. Its macOS 27 requirement and reliance on a private Apple framework are important compatibility considerations.

Visit Pelmet

Vanilla

Free plan Mac

Vanilla focuses on hiding menu bar icons, with additional controls in its one-time Pro purchase. Check the permission requirement and the activation limit before buying.

Visit Vanilla

The facts

PelmetVanilla
Free planYesYes
Open sourceNot publishedNot published
Runs onMacMac
Lowest paid planFree or on requestVanilla Pro: $10, paid once
Plans published12
MakerNot publishedNot published
Websitepelmet.fif7y.commatthewpalmer.net
On menu bar customization software#13 of 25#17 of 25

Pelmet: what it does well

  • Free and open source.
  • Arrange items in three visibility sections.
  • Several reveal triggers and animation styles.
  • Includes replacement items and app launchers.
  • Supports keyboard shortcuts and multiple displays.

What to know first

  • Requires macOS 27; older versions are unsupported.
  • Accessibility access is required.
  • Uses a private Apple framework that updates could change.
  • No vulnerability-reporting SLA is offered.

Vanilla: what it does well

  • Free plan hides menu bar icons.
  • Pro adds shortcuts and automatic hiding after five seconds.
  • Pro can start when you log in.
  • Compatible with MacBooks that have display notches.

What to know first

  • Screen Recording permission is required on macOS Catalina and later.
  • Setup on notched MacBooks may require rearranging menu bar items.
  • Pro activation codes work up to 10 times by default.

Alternatives to Pelmet Alternatives to Vanilla The whole list