Side by side

Mcgic Banner Maker vs MCPlayerTools Banner Maker

Both stand on minecraft banner generators. Which one you can start free with, which one lets you read the code, and what each costs once you pay.

Mcgic Banner Maker

Free plan AndroidiPhoneWeb

Mcgic Banner Maker combines banner design, crafting guidance, and Java command generation. Bedrock users can use the loom steps, but not the generated commands.

Visit Mcgic Banner Maker

Choose MCPlayerTools Banner Maker if you want to preview a Java Edition banner and copy its `/give` command without signing up or installing anything. Its six-layer cap may make it a poor fit if you need more layers.

Visit MCPlayerTools Banner Maker

The facts

	Mcgic Banner Maker	MCPlayerTools Banner Maker
Free plan	Yes	Yes
Open source	Not published	Not published
Runs on	Android, iPhone, Web	Web
Lowest paid plan	Free or on request	Free or on request
Plans published	1	1
Maker	Not published	Not published
Website	mcgic.com	mcplayertools.com
On minecraft banner generators	#6 of 25	#10 of 25

Mcgic Banner Maker: what it does well

More than 40 loom patterns are available.
Commands support banners or shields and two formats.
Loom Steps lists each layer’s dye and pattern item.
Designs can be saved, shared, or downloaded as PNGs.

What to know first

Each banner is limited to six pattern layers.
Generated commands are for Java Edition only.
The preview lacks in-game cloth texture and lighting.

MCPlayerTools Banner Maker: what it does well

Live preview updates as the banner is built.
Choose a base color and stack up to six pattern layers.
Generates a ready-to-copy `/give` command.
Provides command formats for Minecraft 1.20.5+ and 1.20.4 or older.
Free to use without an account or installation.

What to know first

Supports Java Edition.
Banner designs are limited to six pattern layers.
No free trial is offered.

Alternatives to Mcgic Banner Maker Alternatives to MCPlayerTools Banner Maker The whole list