FREEDOM251

Freedom251 › Compare

Side by side

Dude Paywall vs Pigeon

Both stand on paywall software. Which one you can start free with, which one lets you read the code, and what each costs once you pay.

Dude Paywall

Free plan Self-hosted

Dude Paywall focuses on one-off access sales for WordPress posts and pages, with passwordless customer access and Stripe Checkout. The listing says it was unavailable for download pending a full review, so availability is a key consideration.

Visit Dude Paywall

Pigeon

Free plan Web

Pigeon combines paywall rules, subscription administration, and analytics for digital publishers. Its free tier is a demo rather than a transactional plan, and paid plans carry setup and transaction fees.

Visit Pigeon

The facts

Dude PaywallPigeon
Free planYesYes
Open sourceNot publishedNot published
Runs onSelf-hostedWeb
Lowest paid planPro: £29 a yearPublishers: $99 a month
Plans published23
MakerNot publishedNot published
Websitewpdude.compigeon.io
On paywall software#7 of 30#11 of 30

Dude Paywall: what it does well

  • Free plan supports unlimited protected posts or pages
  • Magic links let customers access purchases without WordPress accounts
  • Pro adds webhooks, CSV export, and REST API
  • Stripe Tax can calculate and collect tax

What to know first

  • Each purchase unlocks only one post or page
  • No shopping cart or membership system
  • Paid unlocks require a Stripe account
  • WordPress.org listing says it was closed pending review

Pigeon: what it does well

  • Supports a range of paywall models.
  • Works with many CMS platforms and custom systems.
  • Includes subscriber management and financial analytics.
  • Setup assistance is listed for all customers.

What to know first

  • Free demo does not allow transactions.
  • Publishers costs $99 a month.
  • Publishers has a setup fee starting at $750.
  • Advanced tools may bypass the paywall.

Alternatives to Dude Paywall Alternatives to Pigeon The whole list