FREEDOM251

Freedom251 › Compare

Side by side

Allstate Identity Protection vs Greenlight Family Shield

Both stand on identity theft protection. Which one you can start free with, which one lets you read the code, and what each costs once you pay.

Allstate Identity Protection

Free trial AndroidAPIiPhone+2

Allstate Identity Protection pairs monitoring with managed restoration, while the included features depend on the selected plan. Compare plan coverage carefully, especially if you want cybersecurity tools or family features.

Visit Allstate Identity Protection

Greenlight Family Shield

Free trial AndroidiPhone

Choose Family Shield if you want family identity monitoring bundled with credit protection, location features, and money tools. The 30-day trial offers a way to try the subscription before continuing. Look elsewhere if you need coverage beyond its stated family-member limits or cannot use the required location-enabled smartphone features.

Visit Greenlight Family Shield

The facts

Allstate Identity ProtectionGreenlight Family Shield
Free planA free trialA free trial
Open sourceNot publishedNot published
Runs onAndroid, API, iPhone, Mac, WebAndroid, iPhone
Lowest paid planIdentity Restoration individual: $3 a monthFamily Shield: $19.98 a month
Plans published151
MakerNot publishedNot published
Websiteallstateidentityprotection.comgreenlight.com
On identity theft protection#5 of 25#13 of 25

Allstate Identity Protection: what it does well

  • Specialists manage identity-remediation cases.
  • U.S.-based phone and email support runs 24/7.
  • Family plans can add up to 10 members.
  • Monitoring options include credit and dark-web activity.
  • Members can cancel anytime.

What to know first

  • No free plan is listed.
  • Identity Restoration does not include protection features.
  • Features vary by plan.
  • Consumer trial automatically renews unless canceled.

Greenlight Family Shield: what it does well

  • Scans dark-web marketplaces, forums, and breach databases continuously.
  • Covers up to nine family members on one plan.
  • Includes credit monitoring across all three bureaus and a TransUnion credit lock.
  • Provides identity-restoration specialists and a step-by-step recovery plan.
  • Adds debit cards and financial tools for children and seniors.

What to know first

  • There is no free plan.
  • Some location features require a compatible smartphone with location services enabled.
  • The savings return is subject to eligibility terms.

Alternatives to Allstate Identity Protection Alternatives to Greenlight Family Shield The whole list